Homily for the 26th Sunday in Ordinary Time
September 29, 2024
Really … Let’s take a moment to ponder that question…and then ask ourselves how we came to that answer. Do we define ourselves by our accomplishments, or our history, our title, or particular critical experiences, or our relationships, or some combination of the above?
Another way to get at this question might be to ask, who gets to tell us who we are? Who has the most influence in shaping our self-image? Is it our parents, our partner or spouse, our friends and colleagues, our profession? Or perhaps it’s the world, particularly the world of advertising, which constantly tries to overwhelm us with ads picturing perfect people leading perfect lives all designed to tell us who we are, or at least who we should be. Or maybe it’s the news media, eager to make us anxious with a constant barrage of worrisome
headlines.
I ask these questions because I think the Gospel passage today is very much
about identity, though perhaps not immediately evident. At first glance the passage appears to be about Jesus admonishing his disciples to lighten up, to stop worrying about others who are following him (but not, apparently, to the disciples’ satisfaction) and instead focus on what matters or, perhaps even more, on avoiding those things that can cause one to stumble and stray from Jesus.
Scholars tell us that this section reflects some of the conflicts between early
Christian communities. Mark is framing this part of his narrative to address some of the problems his folks are having with other Christians. Apparently, the early Christian church wasn’t all united in their beliefs, sometimes they clashed with each other, and occasionally even berated one another over differences in practice.
In other words, Mark was trying to help his congregation answer the question of who they are. Will they define themselves over and against other Christians or will they discover their own identity in their personal and collective attempt to follow Jesus, to care for the vulnerable, and to avoid those things that are destructive to self, neighbor, and community? Which brings me back to the question of identity. Note the tone and tenor
struck by the disciples’ statement:
Teacher, we saw someone casting out demons in your name, and we tried to stop him, because he was not following us.
More complaint than observation, and perhaps even more accusation than complaint, the disciples want Jesus to affirm their judgment and action against this other follower because he was not playing by their rules or following their lead. In other words, the disciples seem to have decided who they are and have defined themselves over and against this other person.
· They are the leaders of the fledgling Jesus movement.
· They are more important than others doing works in Jesus’ name.
· They are the inner circle who should be obeyed by lesser disciples.
What’s striking, of course, is that all this happens almost immediately after Jesus chided their earlier arguments about which of them was the greatest. It seems that all Jesus’ admonishment did was to encourage them to give up vying amongst themselves so that they could vie together against everyone else!
This is probably because this identity question can be really, really hard to answer. We don’t come into this world knowing who we are, where we’ve come from, or even where we’re going.
So, the real question today for us to think about is, are we like the disciples, or are we like Jesus? In other words, are we more concerned about what others are doing, or not doing, in their attempt to follow Jesus, or are we working on our own spiritual life?
The passage from James gives us some insights into how we can better our spiritual selves, but that process is directly connected to our temporal selves. James takes time to denounce the exploiting activities of the rich. He is not denouncing wealth as such, rather he is attacking wealth obtained by corruption. He attacks ill-gotten gains and the motivations that drive us to these ends. The passage again exposes unrighteous behavior, behavior which is the product of a "useless" faith. It’s not what we’re about.
I read yesterday the article entitled 6 N.J. cities rank on national list of top 30 safest and richest cities and Summit ranks 13. As Catholic Christians, is that how we want to be identified? Certainly, there’s plenty of encouragement from the culture to do just that. We are encouraged relentlessly to define ourselves through our accomplishments or, even more often, through our possessions. The moment we venture down this road, however, I believe that we’re doomed to a sense of scarcity where there is never “enough” – accomplishments, honor, possessions, money, youth, whatever commodity we’ve decided is our measure – and each and every other person around us therefore becomes a competitor. And before long like those ancient disciples, we’re trying to tell
other people what to do and judging them for not conforming to our expectations.
When Jesus sees this happen with his disciples, he responds by inviting them,
to entertain the peculiar logic of God’s kingdom where the weak and vulnerable
are to be honored and where glory comes through service. This week, he reiterates his counsel that mercy and love must be the vehicles through which we discover and express our identity. And one of the great things about service, love, and mercy is that we never run out of them. There is no scarcity of opportunity to care for others, no lack of occasions to love our neighbor.
Who are you? Who am I?
Christians have from the beginning of our story struggled with this question, so it is not surprising that we struggle with it still. But as we wrestle with it, perhaps try to better understand that identity finally isn’t something we can attain, but only receive as a gift. And one of the primary reasons Jesus came was to tell us that we are beloved, holy, precious, and honored in God’s eye so that we might also hear ourselves called to lives of love, mercy, compassion, and service.
In a few minutes we will baptize these two beautiful children. What examples
will we give to them about how to follow Jesus? They’re watching … and so is God! RSM